Call/Text Us Today(513) 741-3244
Insure Your Needs
Let us help you find the right coverage.
Get Started
Business Insurance
Explore all the options available to you.
Get Started
Home Insurance
Let us assist you in selecting the best coverage.
Get Started
Auto Insurance
We get you the right coverage for the right price.
Get Started
Umbrella Insurance
Get free quotes and dedicated personal service.
Get Started
Life Insurance
Let our agents customize a plan for you today.
Get Started
Specialty Insurance
Get affordable coverage that meets all your needs.
Get Started

We stand by our customers and provide Protection, Service and Advocacy.


At Heister Insurance, we understand that you have many options for purchasing insurance. That’s why we continuously work to provide the best coverage for the best cost. When it comes to protecting your auto, home, business and family, you need not look any further. We take pride in our business and strive to be relationship specialists by providing you with a total insurance solution for all your needs.

Being insured with the best has its advantages. That’s why the companies we represent have consistently earned the highest rating from AM Best, the leading independent insurance industry rating authority .

In addition, when you file a claim, not only are we fast and efficient, we advocate for our clients.

About Us

Our service is top class. We make finding affordable insurance easy. We shop the market for the provider with the lowest price to fit your needs. We will do our best to start saving you money today.

Gain some peace of mind. Let us save you time so you can spend it doing what you enjoy. We can save you money to put towards your future.

Contact Us Now
American Modern Logo
CNA Surety Logo
Encova Logo
Great American Logo
Ohio Mutual Logo
Progressive Logo
RLI Logo
Safeco Logo
Westfield Group Logo

What our customers say

Mike is a wonderful person to work with, not only is he very passionate about what he does but he’s also very considerate of others and there needs. I highly recommend him !!!!

-Matt Lambert

The people at Heister are professional, responsive, friendly and great to work with.

-Christine McTigue

Our family has been with Heister agency for 25 years, and we can’t say enough about the high quality of care Mike and his team provide. They have consistently pointed us in the right direction for our insurance needs, not just focusing on the cheapest premium but getting us the...

-Robb Bittner

I’ve been with Heister for a very long time. They are a fabulous group of people who do a really really good job.

-Joe Brunemann

Heister Insurance has taken care of our family business for literally decades. They are so solid and conscientious in their business practices that several family members have personal properties insured with them as well. How they manage to maintain the standard of treating customers like friends and family in such...

-Linda McCart

Heister Insurance has managed my family’s home and auto insurance for over 25 years. The whole team has always done an outstanding job and they're always responsive, supportive and available. Their customer service and attention to detail are outstanding.

-Roberto Tomodo

Mike and Colleen believe in the power of relationships. They are knowledgeable, and always go the extra mile for their customers, community, staff, and family. Mike is a true leader. You will not find anyone more generous with his time and talents, passionate about serving, or willing to mentor others...

-Carey Wallace

Heister Insurance has managed my family’s home and auto insurance for over 30 years. Mike, Colleen and their staff have always done an outstanding job when we’ve had a claim. They’ve always answered my questions and have never left me guessing about coverage. Their personal service and attention to detail...

-Amy T

Heister insurance is completely different than any insurance company I've ever had. The whole point of insurance is to protect yourself from the unknowns of life. Mike personally came to the house and met with me to review my company policy. He had everything in an easy to read outline...

-Shawn O’Brien

There are not enough words in the dictionary to describe the exemplary customer service that this firm gives. I have been a client of Heister Insurance for over 25 years and this review is well overdue. From the moment the phone is answered to the quote to the instantaneous follow...

-Jeannie Gillispie

GREAT EXPERIENCE FOR HOME AND AUTO FOR MANY YEARS

-Bruce Yeazell

Leave us a review

The greatest testament that our customers can provide is by sharing their experience.

View More

Our latest articles

Read More

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

©2025. All rights reserved. | Powered by Zywave Websites